The short answer
To detect proxy candidates in remote interviews, stop treating identity as one check and start treating it as a thread. A proxy candidate applies under one identity while someone else does the interviewing, the work, or both. You catch it by confirming that the same person is present at application, at each interview and at onboarding. You also watch for the specific red flags US agencies have published, and you build workflow steps that make a swap costly. No single tool solves this. Pair your ATS fraud signals with an ID check from your background-check provider and a camera-on live round. Then send every flag to a trained person who follows the same written process for every candidate.
What a proxy candidate is
Proxy interview fraud comes in three common shapes.
- The stand-in. The applicant is real and plans to do the job, but a stronger friend or a paid helper sits the interview.
- The switch. A strong person interviews well. A different person shows up to work, or the work is quietly handed off after the start date.
- The invented identity. A stolen or made-up identity, sometimes run by an organized group, applies for remote jobs with system access.
The third shape is the one federal agencies keep warning about. In 2022 the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center reported complaints about deepfakes and stolen personal data used to apply for remote IT, programming, database and software jobs. In June 2025 the Justice Department announced coordinated actions against North Korean remote IT worker schemes, including searches of 29 laptop farms across 16 states, in cases involving more than 100 US companies.
Employers expect more of it. Gartner predicted in July 2025 that by 2028, one in four candidate profiles worldwide will be fake, and 6% of the job candidates it surveyed admitted to interview fraud. A Greenhouse survey from November 2025 found that 65% of hiring managers had caught applicants using AI deceptively, and 18% of those who caught it said candidates showed up as deepfakes.
A proxy is different from a candidate reading answers off a hidden assistant. If copilots and leaked questions are your bigger worry, our guide to spotting AI help during interviews covers that side.
Red flags from the FBI and State/Treasury advisories
Three public advisories list warning signs in plain terms. Here they are by source, so you can cite them in your policy.
FBI, June 2022. In the deepfake complaints, the lip movement of the person on camera did not fully line up with the audio. Coughing, sneezing and other sounds did not match what was shown on video.
State, Treasury and FBI, May 2022. This guidance on North Korean IT workers was written mostly for freelance platforms and the companies that hire through them. Its red flags include:
- a preference for text chat over video calls
- requests to send items to an address that isn't on the person's ID
- inconsistencies in name spelling, nationality, claimed location, contact details or education
Its advice was to hold video interviews to confirm identity.
FBI, January 2025. The FBI said these workers have used AI and face-swapping during video job interviews. It flagged the same phone numbers, often VoIP numbers, showing up across different resumes. It also flagged changes to the delivery address or payment platform during onboarding. It recommended doing as much of hiring and onboarding in person as you can.
Every one of these has innocent explanations. People move, and honest candidates use VoIP numbers. A red flag is a reason to look closer, not a finding.
Keep one identity from application to onboarding
Most proxy schemes succeed in the gaps between stages. The recruiter checks one thing, the hiring manager meets someone on video, and IT ships a laptop. Nobody confirms they were the same person. Close the gaps by recording what was confirmed at each step in the candidate record.
Give each stage an owner. The recruiter owns the application and first round. The hiring manager owns later rounds. HR or people ops owns the ID check and onboarding. A short note at each handoff turns a vague feeling into a record.
Workflow controls that make proxy interview fraud harder
You don't need to catch a proxy in the act if your process makes the swap expensive.
- Make the first live round camera-on by default. Say so in the invite. Offer a clear alternative for candidates who need one, such as an ID check before the round.
- Ask about their own history. Questions rooted in the resume ("walk me through the migration you led") are hard for a stand-in to answer well.
- Keep transcripts and compare rounds. When the round-three interviewer can read round one, a change in story or voice stands out.
- Check for reused phone numbers. Search your ATS for the same number on different candidate records, as the 2025 FBI advisory suggests.
- Run the ID check before anything of value changes hands. That means before a laptop ships, before system access and before the first paycheck.
- Ship only to the verified address. Treat a request to send equipment elsewhere as a reason to pause and call the candidate.
- Lock onboarding changes. Route changes to delivery address or payment details through a callback to a number you already confirmed.
- Add an in-person step where you can. Even one meeting helps for high-access roles.
Your ATS can carry part of this load. Ashby's Candidate Fraud Detection looks at device, IP, email and phone signals on new applications, and Bullhorn's Amplify Verify gives identity and behavior signals. We walk through both in our Ashby guide and Bullhorn guide, with setups for Greenhouse and Lever too. For the flood of mass-applied resumes that hides proxies in the first place, see how to stop AI resume spam.
How to detect proxy candidates in remote interviews fairly
A proxy check that falls on the wrong people does real harm. Build fairness in before the first flag arrives.
- Same steps for everyone. Run the same checks for every candidate at the same stage. Don't add scrutiny because of an accent, a name or a country. The advisories flag inconsistencies, not nationality.
- A person decides. A flag from a tool or an interviewer goes to a trained reviewer. The reviewer considers innocent explanations and, when unsure, invites the candidate to a short live call before deciding.
- Plan for accommodations. A candidate may ask to keep the camera off for a health or disability reason. Agree on another way to confirm identity, such as an ID check plus a voice call, and don't count the request against them.
- Tell candidates what you check. Put it in the invite: camera on, an ID check before the offer, and the same person expected on day one.
- Write the decision down. Record the evidence and the reason the same way each time.
Face and voice analysis needs consent first
Some teams want software to compare the face on camera with an ID photo, or the voice in round three with round one. Before you turn that on, check biometric privacy law. Illinois's Biometric Information Privacy Act lists face geometry and voiceprints as biometric identifiers. Section 15(b) requires a written release before a private entity collects them. Other states and cities may have their own rules.
Ask each vendor whether its feature creates a face geometry scan or a voiceprint. If it does, get a written release from Illinois candidates before the session and keep it with the candidate record. Our Illinois hiring rules page has more. This is not legal advice, so confirm the details with counsel for your locations.
Where Carolina fits, and where she doesn't
Carolina is NTRVSTA's AI recruiting agent. She scores every applicant against your scorecard and writes down her reasons for each one. She runs live first-round interviews by video or voice at any hour, and the questions adapt to each answer with follow-ups. Scorecards and transcripts are written to your ATS, so the round-three interviewer can read exactly what was said in round one.
That helps with proxies in one narrow way. Live follow-up questions make memorized or relayed answers harder to sustain and easier for a human reviewer to notice. That is not identity verification. Carolina does not detect proxies or deepfakes, and she does not confirm who is on camera. Pair her with your ATS's own fraud tools and an ID check from your background-check provider. NTRVSTA connects to Checkr, Sterling and HireRight. You set each of Carolina's actions to suggest, ask first or run on its own, and offers always wait for a person.
Where NTRVSTA isn't the right fit: if your main exposure is identity, start with an identity step from your background-check provider and an in-person meeting, because a recruiting agent won't close that gap. NTRVSTA is also newer and smaller than the large incumbents.
Questions
What is a proxy candidate?
A proxy candidate is an applicant whose interviews are done by someone else, or who hands the job to someone else after being hired. Some cases are one person helping a friend. Others use stolen or invented identities, and US agencies have warned that face-swapping tools are sometimes part of it.
Is a candidate who keeps the camera off a proxy?
Not by itself. Bad webcams, slow connections and disability-related needs are all common. A text-only preference is one of the red flags in the 2022 State, Treasury and FBI guidance, so treat it as a reason to offer another way to confirm identity, not as a reason to reject.
Can we use face matching to catch proxies?
You can, but check the law first. Illinois treats face geometry and voiceprints as biometric identifiers, and its Biometric Information Privacy Act requires a written release before a private entity collects them. Other places have their own rules. This is not legal advice.
Does a live AI interview verify identity?
No. Live follow-up questions make memorized or relayed answers harder to keep up and easier for a reviewer to notice, but they do not prove who is on camera. Pair them with your ATS fraud signals and an ID check from your background-check provider.
When should the ID check happen?
Before the person gets anything of value: a laptop, system access or a first paycheck. A natural point is the background check at offer, then confirm the same person shows up on day one.
Want to see how first-round transcripts and scorecards land in your ATS for later rounds to compare? Book a demo and bring your current hiring steps.
Sources
- FBI IC3: deepfakes and stolen PII used to apply for remote work positions (June 2022)
- US State, Treasury and FBI: guidance on North Korean IT workers (May 2022)
- FBI IC3: North Korean IT workers, AI and face-swapping in interviews (January 2025)
- US Justice Department: coordinated actions against North Korean remote IT worker schemes (June 2025)
- Gartner: candidate survey and fake profile prediction (July 2025)
- Greenhouse: hiring manager and job seeker survey (November 2025)
- Illinois: Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14)




